A Comparative Analysis of Snow White Snow White became a part of the Grimm Brothers' fairy tales in and was made into a classic, feature length film by the Walt Disney company in
Image via Wikipedia My wife recently wrote an essay for her college English class comparing Disney's film Cinderella to the literary version told by the Grimm brothers. The contrast was revealing. Whether deliberate or incidental, the Disney version seems to effortlessly recast the story within a fantasy world of dreams without consideration or reference to the personal duty and responsibility preserved in the Grimms' version.
Disney's Cinderella awakens not the moral imagination, but the dreamer's untamed fancy. I am reminded of Lewis' analysis in An Experiment of Criticism. He begins chapter 6 by defining three types of psychological fantasy, the second of which he calls "Morbid Castle-building.
It becomes the prime consolation, and almost the only pleasure, of the dreamer's life. In the Disney film there are no respectable adults to direct Cinderella. The mother is absent or dead, and the father dies early in the film. The leading adult is the step-mother, who offers no substatnive model for parenting.
Grimms' version begins with an ailing mother who calls her daughter to the bedside with the invocation, "Dear child, continue devout and good.
Then God will always help you, and I will look down upon you from heaven and watch over you. It is apparent that the story of Cinderella builds on a child's devotion to her mother in honoring the call to "continue devout and good.
I would be very grateful if you could send me the essay your wife wrote, it would be very useful for my thesis. Thank you in advance. What are you discovering? There is a link to the essay at the beginning of this post. Let me know if that does not work, or if you would like a copy in a different format.
The essay is quite interesting, it gave me a couple of ideas. For my thesis, well, it is not an easy work; I found out that a simple comparison between the films and the written stories is not productive.
I should try another approach. Probably I will have to analyze Grimms' world and Disney's and then try to understand what changed from the origins, how and why. I found that Disney was trying to impose his vision of life by changing some things for example.
I am still at the first steps and I must find the right way for my work anyway. They'll help you on a project like this. I am enjoying your contributions to my readings Blessings to you and your family.Grimm vs Disney Essay Chelsea Cruz Professor Blevins April 12, English Grimm vs.
Disney Most people cannot imagine coveted childhood fairytale with pure sadistic characters, blood, death and neglect.
However, the Disney version of fairytales is totally different compared to the Brothers Grimm version. Unlike Disney the Brothers Grimm version of the fairytales was more about teaching life lessons and these stories don’t always portray a happy ending.
The story of Cinderella is one of the most famous Disney fairytales. Essay Fairy Tales: Disney Vs Grimm Brothers. Fairy Tales: Disney vs Grimm Brothers Everyone at some point has seen or heard of the Disney fairy tales such as the well-known Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella, and so on and so forth.
Many little girls admire and look up to Disney characters like Cinderella and Snow White. Characters like Cinderella and Snow White who were able to overcome the struggle and bad treatment they endure. Disney vs Brothers Grims. Many little girls admire and look up to Disney characters like Cinderella and Snow White.
Characters like Cinderella and Snow White who were able to overcome the struggle and bad treatment they endure. The way Disney portrayed . Mar 30, · Walt Disney & the Brothers Grimm: A Comparative Analysis of Snow White Snow White became a part of the Grimm Brothers' fairy tales in and was made into a classic, feature length film by the Walt Disney company in